If you’re a fan of spice and planning to visit the beachy wonderland of Cape May, stick around. We’ve put together an overview of a few remarkable restaurants in this seaside city that are sure to make your taste buds tingle.

From seafood to creole, each place brings its own unique spin on spicy food. So read on for a guide to the hotter side of the culinary scene in this popular East Coast tourist destination.

The Mad Batter

While the name and logo might evoke Alice in Wonderland, the menus reflect the nautical history of the region, and there’s plenty to impress even the fussiest foodie at The Mad Batter.

From steak to swordfish and even vegan dishes for those maintaining a healthy diet, the array of options is impressive, but if you’ve got a taste for the spicier end of the spectrum, then you definitely need to check out the Southwestern Spiced Salmon. Not only is it coated in deliciousness and grilled to perfection, but it also comes with a healthy helping of butter that has been infused with chili and lime to really amp up the impact.

410 Bank Street

As you’d expect, the main attraction of this long-established eatery is seafood, most of which has been plucked fresh from the waters off Cape May just hours before it is served up.

What sets 410 Bank Street apart is that the overarching culinary style here is more Southern-inspired than many of its rivals. So you’ll be able to tuck into piquant delicacies such as Havana Bay Shrimp and crawfish beignets served with Cajun remoulade.

The main event comes with the house specialties, where spicy voodoo shrimp and shellfish gumbo are the stars of the show, bringing big-hitting flavours to bear on a menu that’s already bursting with inventive options.

Rusty Nail

The laid back vibes of this cool and collected restaurant have made it a real hit since it was relaunched five years ago. And the menu is extensive, covering all the bases for diners with different tastes.

For spice heads, there’s plenty to get stuck into. From signature nachos that are loaded with jalapenos, to tacos that are lovingly prepared with local seafood, the choice is yours.

Lucky Bones Back Water Grille

By this point, it should be obvious that Cape May punches well above its weight in terms of food options, especially if seafood is what you’re craving. And Lucky Bones is yet another brilliant venue which has spice-infused menu items to whet your appetite.

The fire-roasted bacon-wrapped shrimp is especially appealing because lurking beneath the layers of surf and turf is a stuffing made with horseradish that’ll surely set your sinuses off in a major way if you’re not prepared for it!

If fish isn’t your thing, then the grilled Cuban spiced pork chop is the perfect counterpart to all of the aquatic options available here.

Cape May Vacation Tips to Spice Up Your Trip

Cape May is full of wonderful experiences beyond its gastronomy delights. Make sure you take the time to distill the classic Victorian charm, serene beaches, and historic lighthouses.

In terms of eateries, reservations are highly recommended especially during peak season as places like our spicy picks often get booked out quickly!

Also try not to limit your culinary adventure just to these establishments, as local food festivals might also offer some fiery treats. So don’t hesitate any longer, but instead book your Cape May vacation today for an unforgettable feast and more.

Final Thoughts